Not to put you on the spot, but when you make a (loaded) statement like this, you automatically validate this:
You know why? Because when it comes to the subject of Sonic, people tend to stray far from analytical thinking. Pokemon fans do more in depth thinking than Sonic fans, and that is a shame because it took Pokemon fans decades to realize they were buying repetitive shit, and that content actually matters. So by this declaration alone, a fan would go “this is automatically ok because tradition says so“.
Ask yourself if Robotnik (in his current state) appealing? Is he “likable”? Do you enjoy him as a “comical villain”? And to what extent has he always been “comical“?
Robotnik wasn’t portrayed as “comical” in the classic series. All he had were panicky looks on his face, which should be natural considering he got his ass kicked. He didn’t have any ultra silly mannerisms or behavioral patterns shown in any of the games that would give anyone the idea that he was a comical villain.
No, him (always) being “comical” is because the first time Robotnik had a personality was in that retarded “Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog“. And for some bizarre reason, that show gets more props than the one that had some weight to it (all because bitches care about Sonic fucking Amy than Sally, but that’s aside the point). But hey, that was his first personality, so that takes priority, right? Well, the Ninja Turtles WEREN’T always comical, and look what people prefer them to be.
Robotnik, for most of his early career, was a truly evil villain. The most memorable of him taking over the world, disposing of a king or Queen, and often being accompanied by a dark and sinister voice. The writers of SatAM did their level best to convince us that he was a threat worth taking seriously. Otherwise, believing that he could bring an entire world to it’s knees would be a daunting task. Sure, he’s had comical moments, but that wasn’t his entire character. He was, more or less, dumbed down in Sonic Underground, but comedy wasn’t his entire character. That’s a distinction that needs to be made.
But the Adventure games did away with practically all of the comical bits and gave us a villain that was no laughing matter. There was nothing funny about this Robotnik. Well, unless you count his tantrum in SA2 and confusing desire to use the name “Eggman” after being annoyed by the label in the game prior, but that’s aside the point. To drive home how much they wanted Robotnik to be taken seriously, he attempts to MURDER Sonic the Hedgehog. Exploiting his heart, he lures him into a trap and planned to blow to pieces in the vacuum of space. From beginning to end, we see a guy who was so determined to succeed in his plans that he was willing to go the distance to murder the one adversary who has always stopped him.
Does that sound like a comical villain?
Robotnik didn’t start becoming this hard on comical fucktard until Sonic Advance 1. We see a guy with an exagerrated smile, and eyes popping out of his goggles everytime you struck his machine in an ultra silly cartoony fashion. Then comes Heroes where his only real defining moment was being stung to death by Charmy… in a comical fashion. Robotnik in Sonic X proclaiming that “hurting people is wrong” (aside the point, but that just shows me that Sonic X is bullshit), Robotnik now having the voice and personality of an eccentric douchebag, and it all just went downhill from there. Robotnik….. was…. neutered.
“Well in the OVA, Robotnik was comical” and no one cared about the OVA. Hardly anyone cared about Japan’s interpretation of the characters until Sonic X. And why should we? They have the characters written a certain way, and just a couple of years later, they have this drastic change in personality!? It’s like Yuan Shao from Dynasty Warriors being turned into a punchline. It makes absolutely no sense unless you go on the notion that Japan doesn’t know what they want to do with the series, which, if you’ve been crazy enough to read my shit for all these years, makes perfect sense because they don’t give a shit. They have nowhere to take these characters because they ran off all the people that cared about them. We should be vouching for the persona given to Robotnik by the people that gave a damn. And funny enough, those seem to be ones that treated him like an actual threat!
“Well, what’s wrong with a comical villain!?“. They have no depth. Thus there is no reason to be invested in them. You never get the sense that they are a threat, thus you feel no sense of urgency. You feel no need to root for the hero to stop them as they are cannon fodder. Now before any jackass barges in demanding an answer for “why this is a bad thing” as Sonic fans are just prone to bitching and whining about people with grievances against everything wrong with the series, lets look at why say… Team Rocket works as comical villains, and NOT Robotnik.
One, Team Rocket is not the motivator for the plot. They have no input or any real effect on the plot. The central plot of the Pokemon cartoon centers around Ash and his quest to be a Pokemon Master, and that’s via traveling the world, training his own team of Pokemon, and taking on the Pokemon Leagues of several different regions. Thus, Team Rocket’s input is inconsequential. What little contributions they do have are immemorial. We do not expect anything from them. But… Robotnik is the central motivator for every game in the Sonic series. His input actually has weight to it. He is the reason for a lot of the events that take place in the games and other media. Now if you think “ok, he’s a comical villain” but he’s also the main guy who just starts these end of the world scenarios just so he can build…. a goddamn theme park (literally all he’s been doing , then…. what the fuck kind of opinions should people have about him? That he’s more of an irresponsible nuisance who has annoying personality to boot. Lets just take a gander at some of the shit he’s done. He’s enslaved animals and forced to become living, breathing batteries for warmachines, he builds a giant space fortress for the specific purpose of conquest, deceives and tries to kill a guy for trying to protect what is rightfully his, awakens 3 different Gods of destruction for the purpose of conquering the world, commits an act of terrorism by threatening to blow up the earth, and demanding a ransom from the President himself, literally blows up the Earth anyway, enslaves an alien race to harvest their life force, tortures 6 retards into working for him, etc etc. When I see the perpetrator of these events acting like an eccentric manchild who’s too busy arguing with his cohorts, I see the severity of his actions being diminished in urgency because….. he seems….. so……. easy. You’re not convinced that he’s a hard target. And considering how the last 2 games went with him losing control of the Zeti so easily just by being so careless with the conk, and being beaten by a severely underpowered version of Sonic when his weapons are far more advanced than they ever were, you will be left wondering why he isn’t dead yet. Shit, the endings in Shth where Shadow kills Robotnik are the most probable scenarios in the whole damn game. He fights with a fucking SLOT MACHINE! How do you NOT want to kill him for insulting your skills?
Now lets look at a comical villain that DOES work. Handsome Jack from the Borderlands Series. He’s extremely popular! He’s a guy who constantly says obnoxious shit over a radio that is either hit or miss depending on the writing, but often commits some of the most heinous acts by any known to man. Similar to Robotnik! The difference is that Handsome Jack is actually a complex character. There is something interesting about him beyond quips. He has a backstory that gives credence to his horrific acts of terror, and even has a shift in personality when his daughter is killed. On the other hand, Robotnik is an empty trope. One note to the core. There is absolutely nothing to be invested in. He is merely an excuse plot. Why? Because he is written to be as silly as possible. You see, even with a “comical villain“, you can generate interest by giving them serious shit to work with. Robotnik isn’t given the same treatment, so there is nothing to stimulate interest in him. Worst yet, he isn’t even funny.
You know, if Robotnik was portrayed like this fool 100% of the time, there would be no issue. But since we’ve had serious portrayals of the character, even from the Japanese, then we have a disconnect. And…. this might just be me… but after Sonic Adventure 2 where Robotnik’s plot was (supposed to be) far more personal to him, and where he had the most depth out of all his in-game appearances, I would expect more from his future plots. I would expect him to be treated with a little more dignity. A little more respect. But… because SOJ had other ideas, any real potential this guy had for growth was snuffed away to make a clown that isn’t funny, isn’t appealing, and is more irritating than he is endearing. Lets be clear. Sonic fans don’t give one goddamn shit about Robotnik, and this comical shtick is why. He has no popularity. Hell, even the doorknobs of the fandom HATE him.
You get the equivalent of the MCU, except you just get repeats of the same exact villain. There is no value in him, and the only people who think this is ok are the retards who came in via Sonic X.
I am… sick…. of the Sonic series being a mindless comedy series, and I do mean mindless as there is no creativity in the humor that would require more than a single brain cell. And Robotnik is at the center of it all. The way he comes off is… it’s like it’s in your face. Written as though his eccentric “comical” status is popular just because, there’s a certain kind of arrogance to his portrayal. That probably has more to do with his voice actor considering how he’s often used to promote Sonic crap while the character himself continues to diminish in quality. But… no, I’m not going to accept this notion of “always being a comical villain” because that by itself is a validation of his diminished quality. Shredder was a comical villain in the old cartoons, but damn if you can find one soul who would accept his whiny ass today.
It seems like the people who give Robotnik’s portrayal today a pass are those that were brainwashed by Sonic X growing up. That show, more than Nintendo fans, fucked up the perception of the series. You got these anime fans running around trying to force the series to be as cute as possible, and they’re too chicken shit to accept anything higher than Hamtaro levels of content…. I’m rambling again. The real reason would have to be Sega trying their damndest to force the series to be as retarded as possible so that no one can logically take the franchise seriously, thus lowering expectations and increasing ratings… which has failed time and again. But there is no cure for stupidity so they just… keep…. doing this. They just keep bashing you over the head with the same old “WHY SO SERIOUS” shtick because they know their loyalists are sheep who will literally go along with anything they do regardless of detriment.